Title : "I don’t think I know when life begins. I don’t think any of us know when life begins; certainly the scientists don’t."
link : "I don’t think I know when life begins. I don’t think any of us know when life begins; certainly the scientists don’t."
"I don’t think I know when life begins. I don’t think any of us know when life begins; certainly the scientists don’t."
"I don’t believe the religious scholars do. I do know the only person who knows when life begins is the mother of the life that she’s carrying."Said LeRoy Carhart, quoted in "LeRoy Carhart, abortion doctor whose battles reached Supreme Court, dies at 81" (WaPo).
The legal way to analyze the question has been to say that because we can't know when life begins, the issue is who should decide (and to give the decision-maker role either to the individual who is pregnant or to the people acting through their legislatures).
But Carhart's quote seems to say more than because someone must decide, so let the woman decide.
He claims to know that she has a power of knowing: "I do know the only person who knows when life begins is the mother of the life that she’s carrying."That comes after expressing resistance to the idea of knowing: "I don’t think I know... I don’t think any of us know... certainly the scientists don’t."
Why the sudden switch from unknowability to knowability? I extrapolate that it's definitional. The woman knows what's inside is a human being because it's a human being when she believes it is. If so, then for that one person, and for her alone, to believe is to know.
Said LeRoy Carhart, quoted in "LeRoy Carhart, abortion doctor whose battles reached Supreme Court, dies at 81" (WaPo).
The legal way to analyze the question has been to say that because we can't know when life begins, the issue is who should decide (and to give the decision-maker role either to the individual who is pregnant or to the people acting through their legislatures).
But Carhart's quote seems to say more than because someone must decide, so let the woman decide.
He claims to know that she has a power of knowing: "I do know the only person who knows when life begins is the mother of the life that she’s carrying."That comes after expressing resistance to the idea of knowing: "I don’t think I know... I don’t think any of us know... certainly the scientists don’t."
Why the sudden switch from unknowability to knowability? I extrapolate that it's definitional. The woman knows what's inside is a human being because it's a human being when she believes it is. If so, then for that one person, and for her alone, to believe is to know.
Thus articles "I don’t think I know when life begins. I don’t think any of us know when life begins; certainly the scientists don’t."
You now read the article "I don’t think I know when life begins. I don’t think any of us know when life begins; certainly the scientists don’t." with the link address https://welcometoamerican.blogspot.com/2023/04/i-dont-think-i-know-when-life-begins-i.html
0 Response to ""I don’t think I know when life begins. I don’t think any of us know when life begins; certainly the scientists don’t.""
Post a Comment